Title: Where the Mountain Meets the Moon

Author: Grace Lin

Genre: Fantasy, Middle Grade

Publisher: Little, Brown
Publication date: July 2009
Hardcover: 282 pages

Grace Lin, author of the beloved Year of the Dog and Year of the Rat, returns with a wondrous story of happiness, family, and friendship. A fantasy crossed with Chinese folklore, Where the Mountain Meets the Moon is a timeless adventure story in the classic tradition of The Wizard of Oz.

In the Valley of Fruitless Mountain, a young girl named Minli spends her days working hard in the fields and her nights listening to her father spin fantastic tales about the Jade Dragon and the Old Man of the Moon. Minli’s mother, tired of their poor life, chides him for filling her head with nonsense. But Minli believes these enchanting stories and embarks on an extraordinary journey to find the Old Man of the Moon and ask him how her family can change their fortune. She encounters an assorted cast of characters and magical creatures along the way, including a dragon who accompanies her on her quest.

Stand alone or series: Stand alone

How did I get this book: Bought

Why did I read this book: I am trying to read more diversely and this story is set in China, with Chinese characters, based on Chinese Folklore. This sounded just like the thing, and given its many awards, I thought it was also a sure thing. Not so much.

Review:

There is a small poor village in the valley at the foot of Fruitless Mountain where a young girl named Minli lives with her parents in a small makeshift hut where there is barely room for three people to sit around a table and not enough food to feed them properly. Their living condition is mirrored across this poor village where food is scarce, work is all they have and life is hard. But life goes on as it must and Minli finds great comfort in her father’s folktales, told every night (to her mother’s dismay and annoyance for what good do these tales do after all?). Those old stories speak of great adventures, extraordinary creatures like Dragons and important figures like the Old Man of the Moon, who knows the answer to every question. Inspired by her father’s stories and by her mother’s unhappiness, Minli sets out on a quest to find the Old Man of the Moon in order to ask him a most important question: how to change her family’s fortune. In her journey, she befriends a Dragon, listens to more incredible stories and encounters a wide variety of characters – from the very rich to the very poor.

There are many things I enjoyed about Where the Mountain Meets the Moon. The story is intricate with several layers of storytelling (with stories within stories) that at first appear random but combine in the end to form a whole picture. The main narrative focus shifts between Minli’s journey and her parents, left behind, worried sick about their daughter and going through some serious soul searching of their own and both threads are really interesting. The relationship that develops between Minli and Dragon is fun and sweet, the variety of characters presented – mythical or real – add a great additional flavour to the story. And I simply cannot argue against the essential idea that stories are important and even vital to people’s well being.

The writing is lovely and the book is interspersed with beautiful illustrations. I also loved reading this review by Jane at Dear Author who describes the experience of reading this book with her child.

Having said all that…

Watch me as I get all philosophical. Also: SPOILERS.

First of all: I would argue that the mother got the short end of the stick and I felt that was so unfair. It is proposed that it was her unhappiness and rancour that moves Minli to set out in her adventures. And in a great moment of soul searching the mother realises that she needs to change, that it is her fault that Minli left and that she can’t allow this bitterness to take over their lives. I appreciate the exploration of the idea about how a parent’s stance in life (happiness, unhappiness) can and will make an impact on a child’s well being. However, how can anyone begrudge a mother for being bitter and sad for not being able to feed her daughter properly? For being so dirty poor? That the father is hailed as a hero for being content and preferring to spend his life telling stories – not that there is nothing wrong with that – whereas the mother is vilified because she is aware of their crappy conditions and hates it, is I feel, utterly, utterly unfair.

But that fits with the overall message or lesson proposed in the story. You see, in the end Minli comes to realise that there are more important things in life than riches. That thankfulness, faith, family are worth more than gold. In the end, she does not ask the question to the Old Man of the Moon and she says:

“Why would we want to change our fortune?”

Well, let me cry HOGWASH. How about because you are so poor you barely have enough to eat? Because you are so poor you can’t afford the extra handful of rice to feed a pet goldfish?

I mean, do I agree with the positive aspects of thankfulness, faith, resilience and family affection? Of course I do. There is nothing wrong about being content with what you have, and extreme want is undoubtedly the source of many evils in the world. But there is nothing wrong with ambition, with wanting to improve one’s life in material ways either. I think this message is pretty rotten actually, considering how there are children actually RIGHT NOW dying of hunger and please don’t tell me that being thankful and having faith are better than to want to change one’s fortune. They are not. There is no dignity in going hungry and no one should have to endure that.

Taking into consideration this is a book for children, I actually think this sends a harmful message. I think I would have been ok with the idea that thankfulness and faith might HELP changing one’s fortune; might help overcome anything that life throws at you – but as you can see from the above quote, it is not a case of wanting to change one’s fortune at all in the end.

This grieves me all the more when it comes to the climax point in the story, after Minli realises she has everything she wants, goes back home and is very fortunate to find a precious pearl that will effectively change her family’s fortune ANYWAY. The finding of the pearl is a mixture of luck as well as merit from being a good kid rather than actively doing something. You know what is worse? The family doesn’t even use the peal to improve their lives. They present it to the emperor who in turn is so thankful, he presents them with riches. How about them apples?

I have taken under consideration the fact that the author has attempted to create a tale with an authentic Chinese feel that follows traditional Chinese beliefs. Therefore, Where the Mountain Meets the Moon should be an accurate representation of historical folktales (although I can’t attest to any of these assertions since I am an outsider and do not want to be appropriative nor am I an expert in Chinese culture, tradition, or folklore). I can’t really say but even if it is, even if it does recreate traditional Chinese beliefs, I feel that I can still argue when it comes to the moral lesson proposed here and its philosophy. Especially considering that the story is 1) fantasy 2 ) written only a few of years ago therefore from a thoroughly modern perspective.

All that said, even though I enjoyed parts of Where the Mountain Meets the Moon a great deal, I felt discomfited by the message presented in the end which in turn, made me question the entire book.

Notable Quotes/ Parts:

Far away from here, following the Jade River, there was once a black mountain that cut into the sky like a jagged piece of rough metal. The villagers called it Fruitless Mountain because nothing grew on it and birds and animals did not rest there.
Crowded in the corner of where Fruitless Mountain and the Jade River met was a village that was a shade of faded brown. This was because the land around the village was hard and poor. To coax rice out of the stubborn land, the fields had to be flooded with water. The villagers had to tramp in the mud, bending and stooping and planting day after day. Working in the mud so much made it spread everywhere and the hot sun dried it onto their clothes and hair and homes. Over time, everything in the village had become the dull color of dried mud.

One of the houses in this village was so small that its wood boards, held together by the roof, made one think of a bunch of matches tied with a piece of twine. Inside, there was barely enough room for three people to sit around the table — which was lucky because only three people lived there. One of them was a young girl called Minli.
Minli was not brown and dull like the rest of the village. She had glossy black hair with pink cheeks, shining eyes always eager for adventure, and a fast smile that flashed from her face. When people saw her lively and impulsive spirit, they thought her name, which meant quick thinking, suited her well. “Too well,” her mother sighed, as Minli had a habit of quick acting as well.

Ma sighed a great deal, an impatient noise usually accompanied with a frown at their rough clothes, rundown house, or meager food. Minli could not remember a time when Ma did not sigh; it often made Minli wish she had been called a name that meant gold or fortune instead. Because Minli and her parents, like the village and the land around them, were very poor. They were barely able to harvest enough rice to feed themselves, and the only money in the house was two old copper coins that sat in a blue rice bowl with a white rabbit painted on it. The coins and the bowl belonged to Minli; they had been given to her when she was a baby, and she had had them for as long as she could remember.

What kept Minli from becoming dull and brown like the rest of the village were the stories her father told her every night at dinner. She glowed with such wonder and excitement that even Ma would smile, though she would shake her head at the same time. Ba seemed to drop his gray and work weariness — his black eyes sparkled like raindrops in the sun when he began a story.

Rating: I honestly do not know how to rate this. I was so let down by the message that it basically ruined the whole thing for me. I am going to cop-out and say: NO RATE

Reading Next: The Boneshaker by Kate Milford

Buy the Book:

Ebook available for google, nook and sony

Tagged with →  
Share →

14 Responses to Book Review: Where the Mountain Meets the Moon by Grace Lin

  1. Megan says:

    Fascinating discussion. While I think the message–you can be happy with what you have without being rich or famous–is an important one for middle class American children to hear (heck, that was the commencement speaker’s main point at my brother’s recent college graduation ceremony), I agree that the context of abject poverty is highly problematic. I haven’t read the book, but it doesn’t sound like it would have been that hard to make it less objectionable: make the family poor but comfortable and have the mother have an ax to grind because, say, she and a sister married equally poor men but her sister’s husband became wealthier while her husband just told stories.

    As for whether the moral is in line with Chinese culture, I’m kind of ambivalent. Now, I’m not Chinese nor am I an expert on China’s myths and fables, but I have studied China for nearly a decade, and I can see the argument going either way, at least in terms of traditional culture. Traditional Confucian culture emphasized knowing your place and obeying your elders/relational superiors; on the other hand, imperial China had one of the few (if not the only) feudal cultures that allow anyone, even peasants, to rise in status and wealth through the exam system.

    I guess the fact that this message of “it’s okay to not be rich and still be happy with your life” being paired with abject poverty hasn’t been raising alarm bells in people’s heads just goes to show how separated many Americans are from real poverty.

  2. Linda W says:

    Hi. I love this blog and the discussions you raise. I also appreciate the passion with which you argue books. I read Where the Mountain Meets the Moon–I even wrote part of my master’s thesis on it. I had a totally different take on the book. I guess we all see things differently. I accepted the book at face value–as a mythical heroine’s journey, rather than a book preaching against the evils of world poverty and hunger. I really don’t think that was the author’s intent, nor do I want to imply that books that have that message aren’t needed. The trope of the resilient heroine works for me. I also enjoyed the journey that Minli’s parents undertake during the story. I found it refreshingly different from many fairy tales where riches are the usual result along with the message that money will “magically” solve all of your problems.
    The value of community really comes through in the book. The friends Minli gains on her journey made her “rich.” And <> her fortune did change on the journey. <>

  3. Alice says:

    First off, I believe this is the first book of a planned trilogy, but I’m not sure if it will still have the same main character.

    Second, I read this book last year so my memory might be a little fuzzy on the details.

    Therefore, Where the Mountain Meets the Moon should be an accurate representation of historical folktales

    It’s somewhat accurate in terms of Chinese folklore, especially if you account into the fact that the even more traditional ones have women/girls really really subjugated and were always portrayed as either a villain or self sacrificing doormat. Ok, not doormats, but there’s also this insane philosophy for women (especially) that enduring hardship without complaint or asking for anything back (again, martyrdom without even the acknowledgement of said sacrifices) will lead to happiness. Something about silently existing for others and other people will recognize and greatly reward said female. It’s like, if a woman even says she’s working hard, that counts as bragging and thus her “fortune” will diminish. Something about not seeking fortune, but fortune will come to those who work hard, etc. Don’t ask me why. I’ve watched it growing up, asking my relatives about it…I still don’t fully understand.

    I could go on and on if you’d like to hear more, but basically, when I read the story it really did bring me back to my childhood stories. If you think about it, Minli only went on this journey for her parents (i.e. mother’s) sake and not for her own ambitions. She still had a male companion, even if in dragon form and at the end, she sacrificed her own question to save her family to help out her male companion.

    And as with all my childhood stories of female resilience, Minli is greatly rewarded for being all the self-sacrificing. So, yes, for her to gain the wealth and fortune really was for her to give her question away, give the pearl away and go home and through that, the shadow of the mountain would finally be lifted and everyone saved because she was selfless. It has more to do with the journey and all the various stories she heard, than about terrible poverty. For a child living in poverty, if she never knew a different world, it’s hard for her to want anything more. At the same time, Minli was written to not be tempted by material goods.

    I’m not trying to defend it (goodness knows I even felt kind of eh about some of the ideas), but this might help…

    I believe there was a discussion a while back here and around the blogging community about how sometimes historical stories had current female/male mentalities superimposed on settings that would totally not have existed for that time period. For me, whether I agreed or not with the morals of the story, it felt true to the historical/mystical Chinese folklore times. This was not a 20th century adult woman with modern ideas living and changing a different era.

    I didn’t read the book as any form of moral teachings. If there were any, it was more along the lines of community helping each other to rise above any hardship. Not to be tempted by selfishness (or else one would end up like the Tiger or the Monkeys). Instead, selfless acts and caring about others will bring good fortune. Again, I could go on…

    Also, the part about the father being the good example and the mother being the bad…I thought it was the author’s attempt at inside humor even though I didn’t quite like it either. In traditional reality, the roles were flipped. Mothers raise their children to be content with their life and Fathers seeking material ambition. There were actually a few flips like that, but never that obvious.

    Also, Linda W…may I read your thesis? :D I’d love to know what you thought.

  4. Linda W says:

    You’re welcome to do so!

  5. “But there is nothing wrong with ambition, with wanting to improve one’s life in material ways either. I think this message is pretty rotten actually, considering how there are children actually RIGHT NOW dying of hunger and please don’t tell me that being thankful and having faith are better than to want to change one’s fortune. They are not. There is no dignity in going hungry and no one should have to endure that.”

    You are SO RIGHT, Ana.

  6. audrey j says:

    I thought it was interesting,well written and taught a good lesson on being thankful of what you have not what you want. It also displays the trouble people will got threw for family.I loved the adventure and the people and friends Minli meets on the way to the never ending mountain and how the wisdom of the old man of the moon over came the problem with her fortune without a question.In the end I realized that thankful I should be for what I have.

  7. Lilcrum says:

    I read this and I could right a report on it thank u ????

  8. anshika says:

    your where the mountain meets the moon is wonderful and it also contains easy words but, there is a problem that you are not making movie it is important to make movie so that I and my whole class can start reading your book.

  9. Dayii says:

    When I say that I love this story, I LOVE this story! It’s one of those chinese tales that always get you interested in a split second! Everything just goes together well and makes sense and there’s a reason for everything! The imagery that forms in your head when reading this book makes it seem like it’s a movie that you don’t want to stop watching (not even for a bathroom break)! I cant say enough, but for now I’m in love with this book!

  10. [...] Book Review (spoiler included):  http://thebooksmugglers.com/2012/06/book-review-where-the-mountain-meets-the-moon-by-gracie-lin.ht… [...]

  11. Em says:

    I COMPLETELY disagree. One, you definitely have your facts wrong. She didn’t say “Why would we want to change our fortune?,” that was Da-A-Fu. Also, the moral is to be THANKFUL! They had enough to eat! Read the BOOK before you write a review, thank you very much!

  12. Em says:

    I COMPLETELY disagree. One, you definitely have your facts wrong. She didn’t say “Why would we want to change our fortune?,” that was Da-A-Fu. Also, the moral is to be THANKFUL! They had enough to eat! Read the BOOK before you write a review, thank you very much! You even wrote in the URL link “by Gracie Lin!”

  13. Mackenzie says:

    I loved this book. I read it twice in one day I loved it so much. I think the moral of the story is you should be thankful for what you have. I loved the fact that Minli used her one wish for the Dragon, and she was not selfish and took it for herself. She realized what she had and she was thankful for it

  14. Anonymous says:

    no good

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Current month ye@r day *

:D :-) :( :o 8O :? 8) :lol: :x :P :oops: :cry: :evil: :twisted: :roll: :wink: :!: :?: :idea: :arrow: :| :mrgreen: