Title: Please Ignore Vera Dietz

Author: A. S. King

Genre: Contemporary YA

Publisher: Knopf Books for Young Readers
Publication Date: October 2010
Hardcover: 336 pages

Stand alone or series: Stand alone

Vera’s spent her whole life secretly in love with her best friend, Charlie Kahn. And over the years she’s kept a lot of his secrets. Even after he betrayed her. Even after he ruined everything.

So when Charlie dies in dark circumstances, Vera knows a lot more than anyone—the kids at school, his family, even the police. But will she emerge to clear his name? Does she even want to?

Edgy and gripping, Please Ignore Vera Dietz is an unforgettable novel: smart, funny, dramatic, and always surprising.

Why did I read this book: Everybody and their dogs are loving it so much: Twitter people, authors, readers and bloggers. I have heard nothing but praise for this book. It even got starred reviews from Kirkus and Publishers Weekly. I just had to read it too.

How did I get this book: Bought.

Review:

Dear readers: Please Ignore Vera Dietz is a heartbreaking book. Probably one of the most heartbreaking books I have ever read and when I say heartbreaking, I do mean it. It is a sad book, difficult to read and as I finished it, I sobbed my heart out, out-loud, feeling like I would drown in my own tears. Just thinking about it makes me want to start crying all over again. Yes, Please Ignore Vera Dietz is unflinchingly sad and all the more sad because of its unwavering realism. Emotional reaction aside, it’s also an extremely well-written book, with beautiful prose and a narrative structure that works and with characters that you both want to yell at and hug close to your heart.

The funny thing is how wary I was when I started reading Please Ignore Vera Dietz. My first encounter with A.S. King’s books was not was not very successful and I thought that The Dust of 100 Dogs had great potential (its premise, the prose, the narrative) but it never lived up to it. And when I started Please Ignore Vera Dietz, I was startled by how Vera’s voice reminded me of that other book and by the similarities in the structure of both novels, alternating between past and present and building up to reveal a mystery. The main difference is how this time around, there is cohesion between past and present and how the resolution is handled with more care. As for the voice, soon enough Vera became her own person, wholly different from Saffron/Emer. In that sense, to me, Please Ignore Vera Dietz is a much superior book to The Dust of 100 Dogs and I am glad that I gave the author another chance.

But what is it about? Vera Dietz and her secrets. Vera Dietz and her family’s history. Vera Dietz and her best friend Charlie Kahn who just died in tragic circumstances. Vera Dietz trying to get on with her life after that but finding it very hard because of her secrets, because of her family’s history, because Charlie won’t let her.

Her entire life, Vera has loved Charlie, her next door neighbour, her best friend, her first love. Then that love turned into hatred and the story follows Vera now, after Charlie died and Vera then, torn between friendship and love and ultimately hate. Add to that alternating narrative, a couple of chapters from Vera’s dad perspective, a few more from a Pagoda and from a dead kid (adding a bit of fantastic realism to the mixture) and ergo, you have all that you need to put the puzzle pieces together. And by the time the reader does, it is not hard to understand both the love for Charlie but the hatred too and how it is possible to feel both at the same time for the same person.

The mystery of how Charlie died – something that only Vera knows, and only Vera can clear his name after horrible accusations have been made – and what made Vera hate him is what drives the plot forward and what keeps the reader on the edge to find out. But the real tragedy of the book, the real story that the author is telling is the one that is flawlessly woven in the narrative. Because Vera, and Charlie and Vera’s father are united by something other than Charlie’s death: they are united by how he lived, abused by his parents and witnessing his mother being abused every single day; by Vera and her father’s silence (“please ignore it, Vera”) in the face of that abuse; by how they are all trapped by poverty and prejudice and small-town minds. Vera’s father brought her up by himself after her mother left a few years back and he is strict and aloof, he demands and expects Vera to work from a very early age so that she can learn the real value of money as much as he expects her not to go on dates so she won’t turn into a slut or how he expects her not to drink so she won’t turn into an alcoholic just like him and his father before him. And even with all that, it is undeniable that Vera’s father does all that because of love.

With that sort of upbringing, with that sort of unreasonable expectations, with that sort of pressure, it is not a surprise that Vera and Charlie are messed up kids. Vera will not go into a date because SURELY she WILL become just like her mother, perhaps a stripper and end up with no future at all; Charlie will not admit he loves Vera because SURELY he WILL be abusive and violent just like his father.

It is a horrible, poisonous environment they live in where the idea of destiny (and genetics even, as idiotic as it may sound from outsiders who know better) keep them both trapped in a vicious circle and because they are both failed by the ones that would help them getting away from it, i.e. their parents it is all down to Vera and Charlie to try and break away on their own. We know that Charlie didn’t and this is part of what makes it heartbreaking. Because it leaves Vera in such a lonely, cumbersome life where breathing is hard, getting away is hard, trying to see is hard but by the end of the book, there is definite hope in the horizon.

I am trying really hard not to spoil the book by not giving away details of the plot. But I can say that Please Ignore Vera Dietz is the sort of book that is not bound by the confines of its covers. It made me think beyond the book, about real life, and real kids going through shit like Vera and Charlie go through, about being silent, about ignorance and poverty and horrible circumstances and what it can do to people. That is also made me care so much for fictional characters that I hope for their lives – Vera’s and her father’s – to be better after I close the book can only attest to the strength of this story.

The more I think about the book, the more I like it and I would not be surprised if it made its way into my top reads of 2010.

The only other thing I can say is: please don’t ignore this gem of a book.

Notable Quotes/ Parts: I loved this part (which is part of Vera’s vocab exercises too by using certain words):

Instead, my parsimonious father launches into a ten-minute-long lecture about how working for a living is hard and kids today don’t get it because they’re given allowances they don’t earn. Seemingly, this is character-building. Apparently, most kids would be thankful. Allegedly, I’m the only kid in my school who isn’t “spoiled by our culture of entitlement”. My mother left us when I was twelve. She found a man who was not as parsimonious as my father and they moved to Las Vegas, Nevada, which is two thousand five hundred miles away. She doesn’t visit. She doesn’t call. She sends me a card on my birthday with fifty dollars in it, which my father nags me about until I finally go to the bank and deposit it. And so, for all six years she’s been gone, I have $337 to show for having a mother. Day says that thirty seven bucks is good interest. He doesn’t see the irony in that. He doesn’t see the word interest as anything not connected to money because he’s an accountant and to him, everything is a number. I think $37 and no mother and no visits and or phone calls is shitty interest.

Additional Thoughts: I have noticed that the majority of my favourite reads so far this year have been Contemporary YA. Thus, I am proclaiming 2010, The Year of Contemporary YA. I mean, this was the year when I discovered John Green, E. Lockhart and Jaclyn Moriarty, three of my new faves. But also debut authors and works like The Sky is Everywhere by Jandy Nelson, The Space Between Trees by Katie Williams and now Please Ignore Vera Dietz (ok, not really a debut for a worthy sophomore effort).

So who else do I need to discover? Recommendations are very welcomed.

Rating: 9 – Damn Near Perfection

Reading Next: The Shadow Speaker by Nnedi Okorafor

Tagged with →  
Share →

18 Responses to Book Review: Please Ignore Vera Dietz by A. S. King

  1. katiebabs says:

    Sounds like a heartbreaking and rough read. May have the think about this one. I need to read some light and fluffy for awhile.

  2. RK Charron says:

    Hi :)
    Thank you for the amazing review.
    I was deliberating about this novel & your “Damn Near Perfection” rating & indepth review put it on my ToBeRead list.
    Thanks again,
    RKCharron

  3. Kris says:

    I LOVED Dust of 100 Dogs and can’t wiat to get this book. It sounds sad but the quote you use seems funny, which is what i loved about the first book. King has a way of being funny and serious at the same time. Thanks for the review!

  4. Jedwords says:

    This one is in my top ten, too. I read an ARC of it this summer. I thought you were wrong (and too snark that month) on her debut. I think the more literal-minded don’t get into it as much, which is why you probably liked this one better. My students loved it and are eating this one up too. I think King is an author to watch

  5. Doret says:

    I need to get my copy book from my co-worker.

    Compromised by Ayarbe is Contemporary YA, and its
    one of my favorites of 2010. Loved it

    Glimpse by Williams is very good and intense, especially if you like Hopkins.

    Behemoth by Westerfeld.
    I thought Levaithan was good with potential. This second book I couldn’t stop reading. Loved it.

  6. Ana says:

    @ KB – It is those things and I needed something really light after I read it.

    @ RK – Thank you, hope you enjoy it as much as I did! :D

    @ Kris – That is interesting: I know what you mean by the quote being funny, because it is, but I find it more heartbreaking than funny. :(

  7. Ana says:

    @ Jedwords: I am glad that you liked King’s other book so much, but my problems weren’t because I was taking things literally, but more with the overall storyarc and its execution, character’s motivation, etc, which I thought did not live up to the great premise.

    @ Doret – thanks for the recommendations! I will make sure to check them. I already read Behemoth and LOVED it. :D

  8. Lenore says:

    YAY! Though I loved Dust of 100 Dogs equally :)

  9. Chachic says:

    Oh wow, sounds like a powerful read. I’m interested but I think I have to prepare before I read something like this. It looks like it’s not an easy read.

    Some of my favorite contemporary YA reads this year are Jellicoe Road, Going Too Far, and Honey, Baby, Sweetheart (recommended by Angie). Another series recommended by both Michelle and Angie is the President’s Daughetr series by Ellen Emerson White. I’ve only read the first two books but I heard that the last two are a lot better.

  10. This is an absolutely superb book – and yes, I cried, too. Some things hit so close to home for me that I couldn’t get through it all at one time, and had to read it in several sittings. I loved D100D, but this one I love even more. It is, I think, destined to become a classic. And, ach, it would make a phenomenally good movie.

  11. Jedwords says:

    If there’s anything I’ve learned in my many years teaching it’s that everyone has a different opinion based on their own personal experiences, expectations and ideas (Which is why I don’t often read review pubs.) I tend to approach reading with a less critical mind. But I did find Vera Dietz a lot funnier than you seem to have. That’s all I meant when I wrote ‘literal minded’. You’re reading with reviewing in mind, and looking for things that other readers might not even be thinking about. My bad. Probably the wrong term to use!

  12. Christine says:

    Thanks, Ana. It’s on my list.

  13. krystelle reeves says:

    The Adoration of Jenna Fox woke up from a comma after a year. She tried to figure out who she is. she has to watch these video’s about her before the accident

  14. Danielle says:

    My English teacher recomended this one to me. I’m not sure what she’s saying by this, but I think I’ll definitly give it a go.

  15. [...] this as a great read for older teens. Read other excellent (and more in depth) reviews at: The Book Smugglers, A Chair, a Fireplace and a Tea Cozy, and Reading [...]

  16. [...] Book Smugglers sum up Vera Dietz and Vera’s and Charlie’s world as “a horrible, poisonous [...]

  17. [...] Passengers is the new LGBT novel by A.S.King and given how much Ana loved her previous two books Please Ignore Vera Dietz (a top 10 book of 2010) and last year’s Everybody Sees the Ants, we were delighted when we [...]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Current month ye@r day *

:D :-) :( :o 8O :? 8) :lol: :x :P :oops: :cry: :evil: :twisted: :roll: :wink: :!: :?: :idea: :arrow: :| :mrgreen: