From Ana’s Dungeon
This episode’s unearthings: About a Boy, the book and the movie.
Marcus is a 12 year old who is having a shit time at home and a shit time at school. He lives with his ex-hippie, single mom Fiona, who suffers from depression and he is in constant fear that something bad will happen. He is the opposite of Will, he is serious, he is completely uncool and his life at home makes him behave as an adult and that makes him stand out at school and be bullied by the other kids.
They meet when Will is having a date with a friend of Fiona, who chooses that day to commit suicide (unsuccessfully) catapulting Will into a situation that he is not comfortable with. All of a sudden he is confronted by real life. And when Marcus decides to adopt him as a friend and as potential saviour to his mother, he can not fight it, for some reason. It would have been so easy to make this into a Will and Fiona story but nothing happens between them. This is really a story about the two boys. About how Will, faced with his friend’s problems realises how his life is empty and devoid of any meaning or purpose and when he finally meets a woman with whom he could fall in love with, he feels utterly desperate and not worthy. He goes through emotional turmoil in order to finally grow up and open his life to other people to come in.
It is really a simple story, Will helps Marcus to become simply a kid and enjoy life and Marcus helps Will to become an adult who cares about other people. At first it may come out as a too funny, too light read about serious stuff. But this is the magic of Nick Hornby to me, that he manages to bring lightness to life’s greatest problems but without being superficial.
The movie is great too. One of the best books-to- movies adaptation, in my opinion. It has a great feel and some scenes that do not exist in the book are awesome additions. For instance Will and Marcus singing Killing me Softly at school. That was laugh out loud funny.
Hugh Grant is perfect as Will and the supporting cast do a great job too, specially the boy that plays Marcus. I highly recommend both.
2 Responses to From Ana’s Dungeon
Leave a Reply Cancel reply
About Us
We are two completely obsessed, sad, sick addicts when it comes to books. Faced with threats and cynicisms from our significant others and because of the massive amounts of time and money we spend at Amazon.com, we resorted to getting books delivered to our offices and then smuggling them into our homes (in huge handbags) to avoid detection. Here we found a perfect outlet for our obsession! Reviews, recommendations, and other ponderings are our specialty.Sponsors
Subscribe
Subscribe to The Newsletter
Book Smuggler Specialties
We do at least two of these conversational-style joint reviews a monthInterviews with authors whose books we have reviewedAuthors whose books we have reviewed talk about their writing inspirations and influencesReviews of books that have made it to the big screenMonthly feature in which we "dare" guest reviewers to read & review books outside of their comfort zonesFeature in which each Smuggler reads and reviews a book that the other has already reviewedWeekly feature in which each Smuggler discloses upcoming titles they cannot wait to readFeature in which we ask the often controversial question: Do Covers Matter?Tags
Adventure Apocalypse Blog Tour Comedy Comics Contemporary Covers Dark Fantasy Dystopia Fairy Tales Fantasy Graphic Novel Guest Post Halloween Historical Horror Kim Harrison LGBT Literary Fiction Lost Meljean Brook Middle Grade Movie Review Movies Mystery Nalini Singh Neil Gaiman Paranormal Paranormal Romance PoC Retelling Richelle Mead Romance Science Fiction Smugglivus Smugglivus 2010 Smugglivus 2011 Speculative Fiction Steampunk Thriller TV Shows Urban Fantasy Vampire Young Adult ZombiesFTC Disclaimer
In accordance with the new FTC Guidelines for blogging and endorsements, The Book Smugglers would like everyone to know that while we do purchase our own books for review on occasion, you should assume that every book reviewed here at The Book Smugglers was provided to the reviewers by the publisher or the author for free unless specified otherwise.
Archives
- ► 2012
- May 2012 (22)
- April 2012 (36)
- March 2012 (37)
- February 2012 (39)
- January 2012 (42)
- ► 2011
- December 2011 (76)
- November 2011 (36)
- October 2011 (47)
- September 2011 (36)
- August 2011 (37)
- July 2011 (35)
- June 2011 (37)
- May 2011 (34)
- April 2011 (33)
- March 2011 (31)
- February 2011 (28)
- January 2011 (36)
- ► 2010
- December 2010 (71)
- November 2010 (33)
- October 2010 (38)
- September 2010 (38)
- August 2010 (36)
- July 2010 (37)
- June 2010 (34)
- May 2010 (39)
- April 2010 (49)
- March 2010 (46)
- February 2010 (38)
- January 2010 (44)
- ► 2009
- December 2009 (67)
- November 2009 (45)
- October 2009 (63)
- September 2009 (49)
- August 2009 (51)
- July 2009 (43)
- June 2009 (30)
- May 2009 (41)
- April 2009 (34)
- March 2009 (36)
- February 2009 (39)
- January 2009 (40)
- ► 2008
- December 2008 (63)
- November 2008 (33)
- October 2008 (51)
- September 2008 (40)
- August 2008 (35)
- July 2008 (42)
- June 2008 (36)
- May 2008 (37)
- April 2008 (37)
- March 2008 (34)
- February 2008 (34)
- January 2008 (31)
- ► 2012
Rating System
10 One of the best books I have ever read9 Damn near perfection8 Excellent7 Very good6 Good, recommend with reservations5 Meh, take it or leave it4 Bad, but not without some merit3 Horrible, barely readable2 Complete waste of time1 One of the worst books I have ever read; I want my money (and a few hours of my life) back0 Did not finish

















You know dude, I have neither seen the movie nor read the book. I had no idea it even was a book, I just saw ‘oh another hugh grant movie’.
But this sounds interesting–I think I will give it a shot!
Oh Thea you MUST , either one of them. Do it, do it!